Stories posted are written by National news Journalists, not by this blog.
Our Blog Tips
Reminder: Stories in this blog b/c these folks who are NOT sex offenders, -crossed paths with- a former sex offender or someone accused of a sex offense, and circumstances (see article/s) resulted in their death. Deaths of any, RSOs or Accused SOs mentioned, are counted in our Murders/Suicides blogs, not in this blog.
Showing posts with label Why - Sexual Circumstances. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Why - Sexual Circumstances. Show all posts

High school football captain, 18, who 'stabbed 27-year-old gay lover to death', says he was sexually assaulted by victim

Case of Sexual Circumstances
12-11-2013 Connecticut:

The captain of the Bloomfield High School football team, who is on trial for the murder of a 27-year-old with whom he had been having a sexual relationship, claims to have been sexually and physically assaulted by the man in the past.

Tarence Mitchell, 18, of Bloomfield, Connecticut, has admitted to stabbing Ronald Taylor Jr - known as 'City' - five times in the torso with a steak knife out the front of his home on November 21, after trying to break off their two-year relationship.

The athlete was recently released from jail and placed under house arrest after his mother posted his $1 million bail with the help of a bail bondsman.

In a 20-page document filed to the Superior Court, Mitchell's lawyer Morgan P. Rueckert, said his client's admission to police supports a their defense that Mitchell was defending himself and didn't intend to kill Taylor, according to Courant.

However Judge Joan Alexander questioned the self-defense suggestion during Mitchell's court appearance and noted that Mitchell initially lied about what had happened, blaming unidentified people wearing hoodies for the stabbing.

In his motion, Rueckert wrote that Taylor, 'an adult, provided drugs to and sexually assaulted the defendant when he was a minor, and then attempted to use the threat of disclosing the defendant's past victimization, along with the threat of, and actual, physical violence to force the defendant to engage in sexual contact'.

The assault was not elaborated further.

Defense: Dustin Musso did kill his grandfather

Case of Sexual Circumstances
12-3-2013 Louisiana:

BATON ROUGE - Defense attorneys told a jury of 12 men and women today that Dustin Musso killed his grandfather in May of 2009. Musso beat him and set his house on fire.

However, Lance Unglesby said his grandfather's actions over many years prompted Musso to kill him. He asked jurors to not find his client guilty of first degree murder, but rather manslaughter which carries a lower penalty.

In court a 23-year veteran police officer testified that she doesn't get rattled easily, but Dustin Musso rattled her. She also said that he was the most "evil and malicious" person she has ever encountered.

Unglesby blamed Musso's family and grandfather for his unstable childhood. As he was being raised, he lived in nearly 23 foster homes.

"Pete Musso molested children," Unglesby said. "He molested lots of children, molested Dustin. The sins of his past finally caught up with him."

Prosecutor Prem Burns doesn't buy it.

"The old molestation, that's what the Menendez brothers did in their case," Burns said. "To pull it out of the woodwork, 'Oh we were molested by out father' to try to get off on first degree murder, it's an easy thing to do against a dead person."

Bethany man jailed in wife's death says wife caught him watching pornography

Is related because of "Sexual Circumstances" which we also document.
1-10-2011 Oklahoma:

Reginald Scott Bartlett, 58, told Bethany police he “snapped” when Cathy Bartlett, 57, caught him watching pornography Saturday at their home.

BETHANY — A Bethany man jailed on a murder complaint in the Saturday stabbing death of his wife said he attacked the woman because he “snapped” when she caught him watching pornography on his computer, according to an affidavit filed today in Oklahoma County District Court.

Reginald Scott Bartlett, 58, is being held without bail in the Oklahoma County jail in the death of Cathy Bartlett, 57. He has not been charged.

Police were called about 6:35 p.m. to the couple's home at 7600 NW 25 and found Reginald Bartlett rolling around on the living room floor groaning, officer Angelo Orefice wrote in the affidavit. Cathy Bartlett was partially clothed on the floor with stab wounds to much of her body. She was pronounced dead at the scene.

Reginald Bartlett was taken to a hospital due to his “distraught demeanor” and was interviewed Saturday following his release, according to the affidavit. Bartlett told police he was “a sick individual” and that he was addicted to pornography.

He told officers his wife came into the computer room, saw he was looking at pornography, slapped him and began to yell at him about a bank statement because she thought he was ordering pornography, Orefice wrote. Bartlett said he snapped, grabbed a knife and stabbed her repeatedly.

Bartlett told police he pulled some of her clothes off to make it look like his wife had been raped, then emptied a drawer out on the floor to make it look like the house had been burglarized, according to the affidavit. There were no signs of forced entry at the house.

Bartlett took the knife used in the attack along with a computer and his clothes and put them in a black bag, which he threw into Lake Overholser, Orefice wrote. After that, he went to a sporting goods store to look at golf equipment and then to Southern Nazarene University to watch a basketball tournament before returning to the home to call 911. ..Source.. MICHAEL KIMBALL

Man allegedly kills neighbor with MS

This is another case of "death by sexual circumstances."
10-6-2010 California:

A Fullerton man strangled his neighbor, who had muscular sclerosis, because he caught his 18-year-old son in bed with the 43- year-old woman, and then dumped her body in San Bernardino County nearly three years ago, a prosecutor told jurors Tuesday.

However, Guillermo Rodriguez's attorney told jurors in opening statements of the 43-year-old man's murder trial that the evidence will not show his client killed Donna Dutton, and that a more likely suspect could be the defendant's son.

Guillermo Rodriguez Sr. is charged with murder, criminal threats and dissuading a witness from testifying.

Rodriguez threw a party Oct. 15 at the Streams apartment complex at 1251 Deerpark Drive where he worked as a maintenance man and lived with his two sons, including Guillermo Rodriguez Jr., and his girlfriend at the time, Deena Derouchey, Deputy District Attorney Steve McGreevy said.

Rodriguez was dating Derouchey while he was still married to Christina Rodriguez, whom he had previously lived with in Victorville near where Dutton's body was dumped, McGreevy said.

Dutton and Rodriguez were friends and the victim brought along her daughter, who was 12 at the time, to the party, McGreevy said.

Rodriguez's attorney, Associate Public Defender Hector Chaparro, said Rodriguez was celebrating because after years of effort he had won back custody of his sons. The attorney did not say why the boys were in protective custody.

Dutton, who had been smoking medical marijuana that night and was drinking, got drunk at the party but didn't stay for dinner, McGreevy said. About 10 p.m., she got into an argument with her husband, Daniel, and went back to Rodriguez's party, the prosecutor said.
The Fullerton police were called sometime after midnight because the party grew so rowdy. Still, about 1 a.m., Rodriguez and his girlfriend went to a nearby liquor store to get more beer, McGreevy said.

They weren't able to get any more liquor at the store, but when they returned Rodriguez saw his son coming out of the bedroom zipping up his pants, McGreevy said. Dutton was in the bedroom nude, the prosecutor added.

"Donna argued with him and said she was going to call protective services," McGreevy said, adding that's when Rodriguez told his son and girlfriend to leave the room.

Dutton could be heard screaming for help and saying, "I just want to go home," McGreevy said.

"The defendant took off his belt, wrapped it around her neck and strangled her until she died," McGreevy said, adding Rodriguez warned the others not to say anything.

The next day when Derouchey returned from work, Rodriguez made his son and girlfriend help put the body in the car, McGreevy said. Then Rodriguez and Derouchey drove up to the Victorville area with body where it was dumped, McGreevy said.

Five days later, hunters found Dutton's body next to Highway 138 in rural Devore in San Bernardino County, McGreevy said.

Fullerton police interviewed Rodriguez, his son and Derouchey multiple times from October through March 2007, McGreevy said. In December 2006 Rodriguez allegedly confessed to his wife at a Fullerton Laundromat, and she went to authorities in March 2007, the prosecutor said.

Rodriguez is also charged with trying to persuade his wife to not cooperate with authorities, and a phone call the prosecutor said will prove that will be played for the jury, McGreevy said.

In May 2007, Derouchey agreed to testify for the prosecution when she was granted immunity from being charged as an accessory to the murder, McGreevy said. Rodriguez was arrested May 31, 2007, and his son pleaded guilty Jan. 8, 2008, to being an accessory to the murder and was sentenced to a year in jail and three years of formal probation.

Chaparro told jurors they cannot depend on the testimony of Derouchey and Rodriguez Jr. because they both cut deals with prosecutors. He suggested that after several interviews with police, the two just told investigators what they wanted to hear to escape murder charges.

Chaparro said Dutton was prone to mood swings and explosions of anger because of her disease and her drinking and drug use. The defense attorney said she seduced Rodriguez Jr. as they smoked "a bowl or two" of marijuana.

Rodriguez Jr. did not tell police initially that he had sex with Dutton because he was afraid they'd view him as a suspect, Chaparro said. The defense attorney said police threatened him with a rape charge if he didn't cooperate.

Derouchey's testimony is equally suspect, Chaparro said.

"She didn't go to police and say she had a change of heart, I lied," Chaparro said.

Instead, she went to an attorney, composed a statement to police and then regurgitated investigators' theory of what happened when Dutton was killed, Chaparro said.

Jurors should be skeptical of Christina Rodriguez as well because she wasn't a witness to the slaying and she had an unusual relationship with her husband and his girlfriend Derouchey.

Before the murder, Christina Rodriguez left the Fullerton apartment with her two daughters when she learned of her husband's affair, Chaparro said.

"She was not happy about this -- upset, jealous," Chaparro said.

After Dutton's murder, Derouchey, who was a rental agent at the apartment complex, was fired from her job along with Rodriguez because they violated rules against co-workers dating, the defense attorney said.

The two then went to live elsewhere in Fullerton and for some reason Christina Rodriguez went to live with them and Rodriguez's four sons, Chaparro said.

Rodriguez told his wife about the murder because he was attempting to woo back Christina, who wanted Derouchey out, and Rodriguez wanted to protect his son, Chaparro said.

"He was so very intent on not letting them get taken away that he would do whatever it took to protect his sons," Chaparro said.

"At the end of the day, the question is going to be, `Is the right person on trial?' " Chaparro said. ..Source.. Contra Costa Times

KS- Mother describes mentally ill son, a tragic death

7-20-2009 Kansas:

A little more than an hour before her son beat a man to death with a board, Rosalinda Reyna struggled with him on a Salina street corner, trying to subdue him and get him to the hospital.

She knew her son, Preston Reyna, 20, was mentally ill, she told Saline County District Judge Daniel Hebert during a sentencing hearing Monday, and she was trying to get help for him before he hurt himself or someone else.

She already had tried once that night to take him to Salina Regional Health Center, and he’d run away. Before the night was over, he would run away a second time.

Rosalinda Reyna spoke to the judge Monday as he considered a motion for a reduced sentence for Reyna, who could spend years behind bars for murdering a man who he was convinced had kidnapped and raped his mother.

Hebert delayed sentencing, deciding instead to refer Reyna, who has been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, for evaluation at Larned State Hospital. Hebert said that without the evaluation, he could not determine if there were compelling reasons to depart from state sentencing guidelines. ..Source.. by ERIN MATHEWS

Salina man pleads guilty to killing man with board

6-8-2009 Kansas:

A 20-year-old Salina man pleaded guilty Monday to one count of unintentional second-degree murder for killing a Mexican national residing in a Salina trailer park by hitting him in the head with a board.

Preston J. Reyna faces a sentence of nine to 41 years in prison and three years of post-release supervision at his sentencing, set for 10 a.m. July 20 in Saline County District Court.

Reyna stood before District Judge Daniel Hebert and quietly answered the judge’s questions as he entered his guilty plea.

Saline County Attorney Ellen Mitchell said Reyna, who has a history of mental illness, was offered the chance to be evaluated at Larned State Hospital to determine if he could use a mental defense at trial, but Reyna declined to go to Larned.

Reyna was originally charged with intentional first-degree murder for the death of Nicolas Chavez-Castro. ..Source.. by Salina Journal

HPD: Boy says he killed man who sexually assaulted him

Posted in Related Deaths
2-20-2009 Texas:

Dead man's nephew disputes boy's story, but says uncle led a violent lifestyle

A 15-year-old boy has told police that he shot and killed a man in northeast Houston this week after the man grabbed him on his way to school and sexually assaulted him, investigators say.

Joe Edward Gary, a 51-year-old ex-convict, was found dead by his nephew at the nephew's house in the 8600 block of Lockwood about 1:15 p.m. Wednesday, police said.

That same day, investigators said, the teenager told Houston school authorities that a man had abducted him at gunpoint as he walked to school and taken him to the house and sexually assaulted him.

The boy said that he managed to get the man's gun and shoot him in the head, officials said. He then went to school and reported the attack.

The boy was taken to a hospital and an examination confirmed that he had been sexually assaulted, police said.

School officials alerted Houston police, and homicide detectives who were investigating Gary's death realized that he was the man the boy said he had shot.

According to investigators, neighbors reported hearing gunfire early in the morning. Police said no charges have been filed in connection with the shooting.

The shooting occurred in the home of Richmond Gary, who said his uncle had stayed with him for about two weeks after serving about 19 years in prison for a drug-related offense.

Gary, 32, said he was not at home when the shooting happened.

"It's tough, but I know my uncle," he said. "I never expected anything of this nature, but with his lifestyle, gunplay comes in."

Joe Gary had a number of convictions on his record in Harris County dating back to the mid-1980s, including burglary, theft and drug-related offenses.

According to records, he also has used the names Joe Henry Wilson and Joe E. Phillips.

Richmond Gary said he doesn't believe the boy's account that he was sexually assaulted. He said he suspects that the boy willingly had sex with the older man, because he had seen the boy at the house a few days earlier, looking at Joe Gary's extensive collection of music CDs and tapes. ..News Source.. by DALE LEZON, Houston Chronicle

Sex offender and roommate slain!

Posted in Related Deaths ---- See earlier article about community protests as to Markvardsen and his fight in the courts to get Megan's Law declared unconstitutional, and taken down, but he lost that fight and was ultimately murdered (See below). (Posted in Related Deaths)
10-10-2003 Washington:

COLVILLE, Wash. -- A convicted sex offender and his roommate were shot to death at close range with a shotgun in their remote cabin in the Onion Creek area, officials said. The Stevens County Sheriff's Office on Thursday identified the victims as Russell Charles Markvardsen, 52, and Matthew Lee Raynor, 32. Both lived at the home where their bodies were found Tuesday night.

The men previously lived in a log home that was destroyed in a May 2002 fire that authorities investigated as a possible arson. At the time, the men told The Spokesman-Review newspaper they suspected arson because of possible prejudice against their homosexuality. ..more.. : by Associated Press.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Wash. man arrested in killing of gay couple

10-17-2003 Washington:

SPOKANE VALLEY, Wash. (AP) | Police and sheriff’s deputies arrested a 32-year-old man Saturday in connection with the slayings of two men at their remote cabin in Stevens County. Richard L. Keenum was arrested at gunpoint shortly before noon as he tried to sneak away from the Valley Assembly of God Church in Spokane Valley, Cpl. Dave Reagan of the Spokane County sheriff’s office said.

Police and deputies had been observing the building after receiving information from authorities in Stevens County and Sandpoint, Idaho, about telephone calls made by Keenum from Spokane.

Stevens County authorities had said they had probable cause to arrest the man in connection with the slayings of two men four days before. Russell Charles Markvardsen, 52, and Matthew Lee Raynor, 32, were shot to death at close range with a shotgun in their cabin in the Onion Creek area.

The two men previously lived in a log home that was destroyed in a May 2002 fire that authorities investigated as a possible arson. At the time, the men told the Spokesman-Review newspaper in Spokane that they suspected arson because of possible prejudice against their homosexuality. ..more.. ALSO: See Google Book

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Washington state prosecutor Jerry Wetle sought the maximum sentence of 67 years, which was handed down last week, for Richard L. Keenum, accused of killing a gay couple in their remote cabin last fall.

COLVILLE, Wash. (AP) — Richard L. Keenum will serve at least 50 years in prison for the execution-style murders of two men in a remote cabin last October. Keenum, 32, insists he found Matthew L. Raynor, 32, and his roommate, 52-year-old Russell C. Markvardsen dead when he arrived to burglarize their home in the Onion Creek area, north of Colville. “I did not kill Russell Markvardsen, and I did not kill Matt Raynor,” Keenum said at his sentencing last week.

A jury convicted Keenum of two counts of first-degree murder earlier this month. Members of Raynor’s family joined prosecutor Jerry Wetle in calling for the maximum sentence of 67 years. Stevens County Superior Judge Rebecca Baker rejected court-appointed defense attorney Lorinda Noble’s request for a minimum sentence of 53 years.

Under state law, Keenum must serve at least 50 years. No motive was suggested for the slayings, but several witnesses said Keenum had made comments about disliking gays. Markvardsen and Raynor were partners. ..Source.. by The Express

Killer Targeted Sex Offenders

This is by far the most confusing case to follow. It is in the Suicide File (because he committed suicide while in prison), -AND- the Murders File (because he murdered a former offender while in prison), -AND- the Other Deaths File (because he killed his father alleging he molested him while a youngster).

Lunz's father was accused of molesting Lunz when he was a child, Lunz's father was not a convicted sex offender. Lunz mentioned this at his trial, and said, that is why he killed him (the reason for being in other deaths blog). The deaths of FSOs will be recorded in a report of FSOs.

Be sure to see the video in the first story. To summerize this story: Lunz however, before he was imprisoned, claims he targeted other child molesters. One is Gerald Estes -from Georgia- who is missing to this date. Authorities have no proof of that claim but Lunz's word. Now, after being convicted of killing his father, while in prison he also killed his cellmate (Nathaniel Taylor) who was a convicted child molester.
12-9-2009 Florida:

Before he killed himself a convicted murderer claimed he targeted child molesters here in the mountains. Christopher Lunz served time in prison for killing his own father.

Now Macon County investigators believe he killed Gerald Estes. Estes was accused of molesting young boys.

Chrisopher Lunz sent a letter to a Macon County detective going into graphic detail of how he and another man tortuted and killed Estes then burned his remains.


Lunz claims he targeted child molesters.

During his trial for murdering his father he said he'd been molested as a child.

This may explain why he targeted suspected pedophiles like Estes.


After getting the letter, admitting he killed Estes, the Macon County Sheriff's Office tried to reach Lunz at a Florida prison.

But he'd already killed himself after killing another prisoner who was also a convicted child molester. They believe there may be more victims out there. ..Source.. by News ABC13

IN LETTER, CONVICTED MURDERED SAYS HE KILLED A MACON COUNTY MAN

FRANKLIN-New details have surfaced in the case involving a convicted murderer who killed himself.

Christopher Lunz, a North Carolina resident made headlines a few years ago after being convicted for the murder of his own father, who he claimed sexually abused him during his childhood and was serving life in prison in a north Florida facility.

However, the case took another turn in September when the 41 year old Lunz allegedly took his own life while in prison. He had also allegedly killed a cell mate of his who was charged with child sex crimes.

But now the case becomes more startling as local authorities say they received a letter from Lunz in which he claims he killed a Macon County man awaiting trial on child sex crimes.

We spoke with Macon County Sheriff Robbie Holland who has more details on this bizarre case, “When we received the letter we met with the District Attorney’s Office the same day and then we attempted to make contact with Lunz the following day. The problem was between the time he wrote the letter and it was delivered to us he had been involved in another homicide within the prison system and had also committed suicide.”

The letter stated that Lunz had picked up Gerald Estes from the Franklin motel then proceeded to torture and kill him.

Holland says Lunz actually confessed to the killing of Estes to the Sheriff’s Office before writing the letter, but after an investigation no hard evidence was uncovered, “We conducted searches and the SBI was involved as well.

We looked in various locations where he claimed to have burned and discarded the body. The problem was we were unable to find any kind of evidence related to Gerald Estes.”

Authorities say they did discover what was concluded to be human hair during the investigation, but it still wasn’t enough to prove Estes is dead.

Sheriff Holland goes on to say the letter states Lunz wanted to come back to North Carolina and lead investigators to the body if they would ensure he got the death penalty.

Holland said that wasn’t possible.

He adds another individual was involved in the alleged killing of Estes and that person did pass a polygraph test.

As for whether or not Estes was actually killed that is unknown but no one has reportedly seen him since he left the motel, “Mr. Estes did not check out of the hotel, but he did leave his belongings behind. Now we know that the reason he left them behind is because he was with Christopher Lunz,” Holland said.

Holland is hopeful that the investigation being conducted by the state of Florida will reveal more evidence on Gerald Estes. He says he will stay in the system until more evidence is produced, but they are not actively searching for a body. ..Source.. by WFSC Radio News/Keith Giles, November 23, 2009

Pinellas murderer commits suicide after fatally stabbing cellmate

9-22-2009 Florida:

NEW PORT RICHEY - If taken at his word, Christopher Lunz wanted to die.

After being convicted of first-degree murder in the slaying of his father, Lunz begged a Pinellas County jury to sentence him to death in 2006. Instead, jurors recommended life in prison.

But Lunz, 41, made good on his death wish today, killing himself inside Florida State Prison in Raiford. His suicide came roughly 30 hours after he stabbed his cellmate to death and injured a second inmate while at Franklin Correctional Institution in Carrabelle, authorities say.

Lunz had been housed at Franklin since August 2006. He was only taken to the more secure Raiford facility after prison officials found convicted child molester Nathaniel Taylor dead Monday morning in the cell he shared with Lunz.

Taylor, 46, was serving time for violating parole on convictions out of Volusia County. He was scheduled to be released in 2016.

Prison officers opened cell doors at 4:55 a.m. Monday and immediately heard Lunz say he had a hostage and warn officers to stay back, said Department of Corrections spokeswoman Gretl Plessinger. An officer talked Lunz into surrendering a shank and noticed Taylor's body.

Officials did not identify the injured inmate but said his injuries were not life-threatening.

Plessinger said she didn't know how Lunz made the shank or the manner of his suicide.

"The details are all pretty sketchy until the investigation gets a little further along," she said.

Lunz and co-defendant William Westerman were charged with first-degree murder in 2005. Authorities said the men drove from their home in North Carolina to Palm Harbor in March 2003 to kill 56-year-old David Lunz. Investigators said Christopher Lunz wanted his father dead so he could inherit his estate, which was valued at nearly $400,000.

The case made headlines when it went to trial in June 2006, partly because Lunz acted as his own attorney for most of the proceedings. Westerman made a deal with prosecutors and testified against his former mentor and roommate, admitting that he shot David Lunz but saying he did so on Christopher Lunz's orders.

Westerman, 29, is serving a 30-year sentence.

Lunz brimmed with confidence during his trial, even planning a press conference to announce what he thought would be a not guilty verdict. It wasn't to be. His dream of vindication shattered, Lunz pleaded for a death sentence during the trial's penalty phase.

"I don't mind," he testified. "I'm not too happy. I'm 38 years old, and I've never been in love, never been on a date."

He also testified that his father was killed for raping him as a child and beating his mother. Lunz called himself a serial killer and said he had killed more than 20 other men who had raped children.

The jury still refused to recommend death.

"I should have known better," Lunz said after he received the life sentence. "I should have known if you ask for death, they give you life." ..Source.. by TODD LESKANIC | The Tampa Tribune

Christopher Lunz Found Guilty In Dad's Killing

6-9-2006 Florida:

CLEARWATER - A man who orchestrated his father's slaying was convicted of first-degree murder Thursday, quashing his plans for a victory celebration.

Instead, jurors return to court today to hear evidence before recommending whether Christopher Lunz should be executed for the March 2003 murder of David Lunz in his Palm Harbor home.

Lunz, 38, represented himself and was so sure he convinced jurors of his innocence that he was planning a news conference to discuss his victory, said two defense attorneys appointed to assist him.

They acknowledged - as did many watching the case - that Lunz did a remarkable job representing himself, despite having demanded that his trial be staged quickly before the defense team had a chance to examine all the evidence and interview all the witnesses.

"From an attorney's standpoint, I don't think the case was fully developed. We never followed up on his [possible] alibi," defense lawyer Keith Hammond said. "As for all the evidence on the table, he did as well as any attorney could do. But I don't think we had all the evidence and the state had three years to prepare."

Lunz and the man who pulled the trigger were charged with his father's murder late last year after a gun stolen from David Lunz's home was found on the bank of a lake near where the killers lived in North Carolina.

William Westerman, 26, quickly confessed to the crime and said Lunz ordered him to shoot his father with a sawed-off shotgun after the son attacked his father during what Westerman thought was supposed to be a friendly visit, authorities said. He testified against his former roommate and mentor and will receive a 30-year prison term in exchange for his cooperation.

Assistant State Attorney Mark McGarry told jurors Lunz hoped to inherit an estate worth nearly $400,000 from his father, whom he had not seen or visited for decades. It turned out the elder Lunz did not include his son in his will.

In opening statements earlier this week, Lunz told jurors Westerman acted alone and that prosecutors had no evidence he ever visited Florida in March 2003. The lack of evidence tying him to the murder scene turned out to be true, but Lunz apologized to the jury during his closing arguments Thursday for failing to present any alibi witnesses.

Late Wednesday, Hammond told Circuit Judge Dee Anna Farnell the defense team was awaiting word from a North Carolina couple who might have testified Lunz was visiting their home the day his father was killed. But Lunz chose to rest his case without calling any witnesses, even though Farnell offered to give him time to contact the couple.

Instead, Lunz chose to focus on the lack of physical evidence tying him to the murder scene.

His father died after a violent struggle, and there was blood all though his house, Lunz told the jury in his closing argument.

Westerman testified Lunz attacked his father and struggled with him, yet there was no DNA, not a single hair or fingerprint left behind, he said.

"There was not one single piece of evidence to put me there, but there was of William Westerman," he said.

When Lunz returns to court today, it will be under extraordinary security. Nine bailiffs surrounded him as the verdict was read Thursday, and Lunz has been wearing a harness that can deliver an electrical shock, if needed, by a bailiff.

At a hearing last week, security officials told the judge they had evidence Lunz may have been planning an escape, said Dyril Flanagan, a second defense attorney assisting during the trial. Also, the judge was told Lunz is under investigation for five other murders, although no details were provided, Flanagan said. ..Source.. by DAVID SOMMER

Murderer, now dead, said he ‘did in’ accused molester

11-25-2009 Georgia:

Estes awaiting trial when Lunz nabbed, killed him, Lunz wrote

Macon County Sheriff Robbie Holland confirmed details surrounding some bizarre twists in the case of a convicted murderer who apparently killed himself a few weeks ago after allegedly committing additional murders in a Florida prison.

Christopher Lunz was living here when sheriff’s deputies arrested him in the murder of his father in Florida in 2003. He had claimed his father had sexually abused him when he was a child. Lunz was extradited to Florida and was convicted in 2006 and was serving a life term there when he allegedly killed one inmate, stabbed another and left him for dead, then killed himself the next day, Holland said. At least one of his latest alleged victims was a convicted sex molester.

Before the recent slayings and his own death, Lunz sent local authorities a letter in which he claimed also to have killed Gerald Estes, who was awaiting trial here on charges of sex crimes against a minor. Holland said he believed the Estes proceedings dated to 2006.

“He’s still listed as missing, we’re still trying to locate him,” Holland said, though, “We don’t have an investigator working on it full-time.

“There’s still an outstanding warrant for [Estes’] arrest and failure to appear,” Holland said. “Until we find definite evidence [of his demise], he’ll remain that way.”

Authorities have searched sites Lunz pointed them to in looking for Estes’ remains, but no evidence was found of his death.

Holland confirmed that an accomplice in the murder of Lunz’s father, who is also serving a life term in Florida, took and passed a polygraph test in which he claimed he assisted Lunz in Estes’ murder, which supposedly took place after they picked Estes up from the Franklin hotel where he’d been staying.

Reports said Lunz wrote his recent letter restating his claim to have killed Estes and offering to help locate the body in order to make a deal to be executed, but Holland said that wouldn’t have been possible.

Estes’ belongings were left behind at the hotel where he was last seen and were never claimed by him, the sheriff said. ..Source.. by David Tell , Staff Writer

PA- 4 shots, 2 deaths, no regrets

Very unusual circumstances. Sex offender meets woman, they begin a relationship, then, the woman's husband kills the woman and the sex offender. i.e., sexual circumstances.

9-17-2008 Pennsylvania:

Butler County jury hears man's account of killing his wife and her new lover

She told him she had found a new love and that their 24-year marriage was over.

She warned him that his medical insurance through her job as a convenience store manager would end when the diabetic ulcer on his foot healed.

She said she wanted to sell the family farm, a decision that would mean a new career for lifelong farmer James Raymond Borchert.

But the final thing out of Esther Borchert's mouth -- the thing that seemed to push her estranged husband over the edge -- was the laugh she shared with her boyfriend.

Mrs. Borchert, 42, and Lonnie Schwab Sr., 49, of Meadville, still were laughing when Mr. Borchert, now 51, grabbed his bolt-action rifle and fired two shots into Mr. Schwab as he stood in the kitchen of the Borcherts' Cherry Valley home. Then, as Mrs. Borchert fled out a door and onto a porch, he fired again. Twice.

"They were dead within seconds,'' said Mr. Borchert in an eerily matter-of-fact statement to police. "Honestly, I don't regret it."

That recorded statement, more than two hours in duration, was played yesterday in the Butler County courtroom of Judge William Shaffer on the second day of what is likely to be a three-day trial. Court conflicts called for a break in testimony today, with the trial set to resume tomorrow.

Mr. Borchert is represented by Butler attorney Alexander Lindsay. The case is being prosecuted by District Attorney Richard A. Goldinger and Assistant District Attorney Patricia J. McLean.

Mr. Borchert is charged with two counts of homicide. Though Mr. Goldinger will argue for a first-degree murder conviction, he changed course from his predecessor and announced several weeks ago that he will not seek the death penalty for the killings, which occurred Aug. 14, 2007.

On the first day of the trial, a jury of seven men and five women listened to a two-minute 911 tape of Mr. Borchert reporting that he had killed his wife and her boyfriend because he lost his temper. The recorded statement Mr. Borchert gave to police was played in court yesterday as the defendant sat beside his attorney, his hands folded, his demeanor calm.

"He was the closest to me. ... He tried to escape. I don't think he got a half a step. ... She made it out the door. She was at the top of the [porch] steps and [the shot] knocked her clear down." Afterward, he set the rifle atop a chest freezer on his porch, called 911, then fed his livestock while he waited for police.

Mr. Lindsay highlighted repeated statements from his client that he had not planned or premeditated the killings. The fact will play heavily in determining whether he is convicted of first-degree murder, which would mean a life sentence behind bars, or a lesser degree of homicide.

Mr. Schwab had been convicted in 1998 in Crawford County of indecent assault and was required to register as a sex offender. ..News Source.. by Karen Kane, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

CA- Suspect arrested in Orange County man's mysterious slaying

This is ONE example, of many, of our new death classification category, death by "sexual circumstances."

9-17-2009 California:

SAN DIEGO — Nearly two years after an Orange County man died under suspicious circumstances, police have made an arrest in the case.

Philong Huynh, 39, of San Diego, pleaded not guilty Tuesday to a murder charge and a special-circumstance allegation of sodomy in the death of Dane Williams.

Huynh also pleaded not guilty to a separate sodomy charge in connection with the sexual assault of a second man.

Police said Huynh lives within 800 feet of where the body of Williams, 23, was found after he vanished.

Williams, of Huntington Beach and an employee of Hurley International, was visiting San Diego for the Action Sports Retailers Convention. In the early-morning hours of Jan. 26, 2008, he left a bar in the Gaslamp Quarter and seemingly disappeared.

Prosecutors said he was visibly intoxicated when he left the bar.

Williams' body was found Jan. 29 in an alley on Landis Street south of University Avenue near Colina del Sol Park in City Heights. The body was wrapped in a blanket and wearing a cap, neither of which belonged to him. His underwear was missing.

A manner of death was never determined, the Medical Examiner's Office said.

Investigators did not identify a suspect until this summer, when a man reported being the victim of a sex crime.

Deputy District Attorney Gretchen Means told a judge Tuesday that the victim met Huynh in the Gaslamp Quarter on June 6 and they ended up drinking and going to the beach. The next day, the male victim woke up in Huynh's bed.

“Previously he had said he had a headache and the defendant gave him two tablets,” Means said. “When he woke up he felt extremely sick and disoriented.”

The man went to a doctor that day and was diagnosed with “benzodiazepine intoxication” and showed signs of sexual assault, said the prosecutor, who described benzodiazepine as a central nervous system depressant. He, like Williams, is heterosexual, Means said.

On Aug. 19, DNA evidence from that alleged crime was matched through an FBI database to DNA found on Williams' body, said police Lt. Kevin Rooney. That led homicide investigators to Huynh, Rooney said.

Officers spotted Huynh driving Thursday on 43rd Street and Orange Avenue just after 5 p.m. and took him into custody.

Huynh, who works for a medical-equipment supply company, lives with his mother on Wightman Street near Shiloh Road, about a block from where Williams'body was found. Police served search warrants at the home and a former address.

Means told a judge Tuesday that several pharmaceuticals were found at Huynh's residence, including a benzodiazepine prescription in his name. The prescription was filled in January 2008, the same month that Williams' body was found.

Some commonly prescribed medications classified as benzodiazepines include, Xanax, Valium, Ativan and Rohypnol, the last of which is commonly referred to as the “date-rape drug” because of its involvement in many sexual assault cases, according to the Center for Substance Abuse Research at the University of Maryland at College Park. A victim is given the drug, which causes the person to black out and have trouble remembering any assaults, experts have previously said.

San Diego Superior Court Judge Polly Shamoon ordered Huynh to be held in county jail without bail and appointed the Public Defender's Office to represent him.

A photo of Huynh was released by police, who asked other potential victims to contact them. He is not registered as a sex offender, Rooney said.

At the time of his disappearance and for months afterward, family, friends and co-workers handed out fliers throughout the city in the hopes of solving the mystery. A $20,000 reward for information leading to an arrest was also offered.

The special allegation in Williams' death makes Huynh eligible for the death penalty if convicted. Prosecutors typically decide whether to seek the death penalty or life in prison without parole after a preliminary hearing in which a judge decides if there is sufficient evidence for the case to proceed to trial. ..Source.. by Angelica Martinez and Dana Littlefield
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITERS

TN- Reaction to "vigilante justice" arrests in suspicious fire death

9-7-2007 Tennessee See UPDATE

Investigators say two Scott County men took the law into their own hands. They admitted to setting a fire that killed a woman.

Detectives say 39-year-old Gary Sellers and 37-year-old Robert Bell were upset about a neighbor's child porn charges.

Police say the suspects went to Timothy and Melissa Chandler's home at 295 Butler Lane the day before the fire and yelled horrible things.

Melissa heard it, but no one expected the men would go back and set their home on fire.


"It was vigilante justice," said Scott County Sheriff Anthony Lay.

Friday morning Sheriff Lay announced the arrests of Sellers and Bell. The Scott County Sheriff's Department worked with the Tennessee Arson and Bomb Division to make the arrests.

"This is a prime example of how an innocent person has been fatally injured," added Sheriff Lay.

Investigators say Sellers and Bell admitted to torching the Chandler home after they learned Timothy was found with more than 900 pictures of pornographic images of children.

"I really wish it wasn't me who got out," Timothy Chandler said. "I wish it was her. She didn't deserve that."

Timothy spoke to Ten News earlier this week about the fire that took his wife's life. He had a gut feeling it was revenge.

According to investigators he was right.

"I can't understand why anyone would set fire to someone's home not knowing who was in there," Timothy Chandler said. "My son could have been in there. There could have been two people dead, at least."

Detectives credit a neighbor who spotted the fire from his home then broke down the Chandler's back door with saving Timothy's life.

"I busted a big enough hole through the door. The husband crawled through, and when he got out we finally got something to bust the door down with," Alferd Butler said. "He went back in and got her."

They performed CPR, but the smoke was too much. Melissa died at the hospital.

A neighbor who did not want to be identified can't believe two men who live just feet away could be responsible.

"It's unbelievable. Things like this don't happen here," the neighbor said. "Everybody takes care of everybody. Nobody hurts anybody. I don't believe they would do something like that."

Both Sellers and Bell are being held on a $1 million bond. Their next court date is September 12th. Timothy Chandler is expected to face the pornography charges in early October.

PREVIOUS: "Vigilante justice:" arrests made in suspicious house fire fatality

Gary Sellers and Robert Bell now face a host of charges for the death of Melissa Chandler in a fire at the Chandler home, in what Sheriff Anthony Lay called a case of "vigilante justice" over Timothy Chandler's arrest on child porn charges.

Melissa Chandler died in a fire September 2nd, just weeks after her husband Timothy was charged with two counts of sexual exploitation of a minor.

Scott County Sheriff Anthony Lay said Gary Sellers and Robert Bell set that fire at the Chandler home as a form of vigilante justice. The two men lived in the neighborhood and were upset about Chandler's arrest. The sheriff said they yelled derogatory comments at the house September 1st and set the fire early in the morning of September 2nd.

Sellers and Bell are charged with first-degree murder, conspiracy to commit first-degree murder, aggravated arson, arson, and criminal conspiracy. Both are held on a $1 million bond. ..more.. by Robin Murdoch, Reporter

Scott County Murder
Scott County (WVLT) -- Scott County authorities have made two arrests related to a Scott County fire that destroyed the home of Timothy and Melissa Chandler.

The fire also claimed Melissa's life.

We talked to residents in Scott County, and we learned that their may have been a motive and about one man who came to the rescue, saving a second life that could have easily been taken in the fire.

"Yes, I'd do it for anybody," said Alferd Butler who pulled his neighbor, Timothy Chandler, from his burning home.

Butler is a life-long Scott County resident, but today he is being called a hero for coming to his neighbor's rescue.

"I had seen it flashing in my window," he said. "I just saw the lights flashing and I got up, looked out and saw the house burning and the porch burning on fire."

Butler says he was acting strictly on instincts.

"I just went down and started breaking the back door down trying to get them out," he said.

Butler was risking his life for neighbors he hardly knew.

"I mostly got the door busted, a big enough hole in it and he crawled through and got out," Butler said.

The homeowner, Timothy Chandler, then went back for his wife Melissa.

"He pulled her to the door," he said, "and we pulled her on outside."

Timothy survived, but Melissa did not.

Two arrests were made in the case this morning by Scott County Detectives and Tennessee Arson and Bomb agents.

Gary Sellers, 39, and Robert Bell, 37, both of Helenwood, live near the Tunnel Hill Area of Oneida and are charged with arson and first degree murder.

This blue house that sits atop a hill overlooking the Chandler's belongs to Sellers.

Bell had been staying with friends just up the hollow from where the Chandler's home once stood.

Authorities think that might explain the motive of Timothy Chandler's murder.

"We had actually arrested him on some pornography pictures of children," said Scott County Sheriff Anthony Lay. "It led them to want to rid them of the neighborhood."

Lay says Sellers and Bell then took matters into their own hands.

"It was vigilante justice," Sheriff Lay said. "This is a prime example of how an innocent person has been fatally injured."

Bell has a prior record but Sellers does not.

Both are being held in the Scott County jail, each under a $1 Million bond.

A preliminary hearing is set for the both accused men on Wednesday in Scott County Court. ..more.. by

2 men plead not guilty in fire that killed Scott Co. woman
10-8-2007 Tennessee

HUNTSVILLE (AP) -- Two men accused of setting a fatal fire at the home of a man sentenced for having child pornography have pleaded not guilty.

Robert Bell and Gary Sellers pleaded not guilty in a Scott County courthouse to charges of aggravated arson and first-degree murder.

Both men remain in custody on bonds of $250,000 each.

On the same day as the fire, September 2, Timothy Chandler, whose wife, Melissa, was killed, pleaded guilty to one charge of sex exploitation of a minor for images of child pornography found on his computer.

He was sentenced to five years on probation but will serve no jail time.

Timothy Chandler was also ordered to pay court costs and register as a sex offender. ..more.. by WATE6



Scott County Murder
Scott County (WVLT) -- Scott County authorities have made two arrests related to a Scott County fire that destroyed the home of Timothy and Melissa Chandler.

The fire also claimed Melissa's life.

We talked to residents in Scott County, and we learned that their may have been a motive and about one man who came to the rescue, saving a second life that could have easily been taken in the fire.

"Yes, I'd do it for anybody," said Alferd Butler who pulled his neighbor, Timothy Chandler, from his burning home.

Butler is a life-long Scott County resident, but today he is being called a hero for coming to his neighbor's rescue.

"I had seen it flashing in my window," he said. "I just saw the lights flashing and I got up, looked out and saw the house burning and the porch burning on fire."

Butler says he was acting strictly on instincts.

"I just went down and started breaking the back door down trying to get them out," he said.

Butler was risking his life for neighbors he hardly knew.

"I mostly got the door busted, a big enough hole in it and he crawled through and got out," Butler said.

The homeowner, Timothy Chandler, then went back for his wife Melissa.

"He pulled her to the door," he said, "and we pulled her on outside."

Timothy survived, but Melissa did not.

Two arrests were made in the case this morning by Scott County Detectives and Tennessee Arson and Bomb agents.

Gary Sellers, 39, and Robert Bell, 37, both of Helenwood, live near the Tunnel Hill Area of Oneida and are charged with arson and first degree murder.

This blue house that sits atop a hill overlooking the Chandler's belongs to Sellers.

Bell had been staying with friends just up the hollow from where the Chandler's home once stood.

Authorities think that might explain the motive of Timothy Chandler's murder.

"We had actually arrested him on some pornography pictures of children," said Scott County Sheriff Anthony Lay. "It led them to want to rid them of the neighborhood."

Lay says Sellers and Bell then took matters into their own hands.

"It was vigilante justice," Sheriff Lay said. "This is a prime example of how an innocent person has been fatally injured."

Bell has a prior record but Sellers does not.

Both are being held in the Scott County jail, each under a $1 Million bond.

A preliminary hearing is set for the both accused men on Wednesday in Scott County Court. ..more.. by



"Vigilante justice" suspects won't face death
12-3-2007 Tennessee

The district attorney will not pursue the death penalty for two Scott County men accused of setting a fatal fire at the home of a man accused of child pornography.

Robert Bell and Gary Sellers have both pleaded not guilty to charges of aggravated arson and first-degree murder.

Authorities allege Bell and Sellers set fire to a home on September 2nd to target Timothy Chandler, a man accused of possessing child pornography.

Chandler escaped, but his wife, Melissa, died shortly after the fire.

Timothy Chandler later pleaded guilty to a charge of sexual exploitation of a minor and was sentenced to five years of supervised probation. He also was required to register as a sex offender.

In court Monday, prosecutors said they will ask for life in prison with the possibility of parole.

The trial date for Bell and Sellers is set for April 10, 2008. ..more.. by WBIR.com

CA- Defense opens in Magalia murder trial

Darrin Lee Pacheco killed: Paul Prestridge 28 because he called him a "chomo lover" (i.e. means child molester lover in prison jargon). See case on appeal!

3-10-2008 California:

OROVILLE -- The defense is scheduled to open its case today in the Darrin Pacheco Magalia murder trial.

On Friday, an autopsy surgeon testified that allegedly during a fight with the defendant's brother, Paul Prestridge, 29, of Magalia suffered stab wounds to the back, leg and chest — the latter thrust done with enough force to puncture all the way through his heart.

Forensic pathologist Dr. Thomas Resk said the wounds were "consistent" with having been made by a steak knife, which at least three witnesses claimed Pacheco, 39, of Auburn had grabbed that night from the kitchen in his brother's home.

Pacheco's attorney, Robert Marshall, has argued that whatever his client did, he was lawfully justified in protecting the life of his brother, Rick Pacheco.

Witnesses at a barbecue in the brother's home on Sept. 3, 2006, have testified that Prestridge, who like Darrin Pacheco had served time in prison, punched the defendant's brother several times in the face, after accusing him of being a "chomo-lover."

A former prison official called by the defense attorney told the jury on Friday that is inmate-talk for someone who befriends a child molester.
Outside of the jury's presence, Marshall asserted that by that statement Prestridge had, in effect, "marked (the brother) for death."

But because there was no evidence what was in the defendant's mind, or even whether he knew what the term "chomo" meant, deputy district attorney Kurt Worley objected to the defense using the phrase to try to "create a defense" to the fatal stabbing.

Butte County Superior Court Judge Gerald Hermansen agreed with the prosecutor, and would only permit the prison expert to testify that child molesters are reviled by inmates and must be placed into protective custody to prevent being attacked.
The Magalia homicide case is expected to go to the jury later this week.

The prosecution rested Friday, after calling Resk, who conducted the autopsy on the slain man.

The county pathologist said the fatal attack could have occurred as testified earlier by the brother's girlfriend, Amanda Baum.

She told the jury her boyfriend had the other man in a headlock on the floor, and heard Prestridge say, "I'm done, I'm going home" when the defendant made what appeared to be "punching motions" toward Prestridge.

Moments later, she claims she saw a steak knife on the floor near the combatants and placed it on a table.

Although a fingerprint expert was unable to obtain any usable prints from the steak knife, he testified to finding the defendant's bloody left thumbprint on a larger butcher knife, also recovered from the scene.

Baum alleges that Darrin Pacheco had the larger knife in his hand when he tried to return to the fight moments later, but that she managed to take it away from him.

The stab wound to the heart caused extensive internal bleeding, resulting in Prestridge's rapid death, Resk told the jury Friday.

He testified that the slain man also suffered numerous scrapes and bruises to his head and body, and what appeared to be a shallow cut to the back of one hand.

The prosecutor asked whether someone stabbed through the heart could have stood up, punched Rick Pacheco once more in the face and walked several feet toward the front door before finally collapsing, as witnesses have testified.

Resk agreed that while that might not be possible for some people, for a man of Prestridge's age and strength, it was "not unlikely."

The defense attorney got the pathologist to concede that because he couldn't determine the precise angle of the fatal attack, he couldn't rule out the possibility of the stab wounds being inflicted by the defendant's brother with his free hand, while he had Prestridge in a headlock.

Although the prosecution had the defendant's brother under subpoena, Worley chose not to call him as a witness during his case.

Last week, Pacheco's attorney had the judge direct the brother to be in court today, as a potential witness for the defense. ..more.. by TERRY VAU DELL - Staff Writer


Trial begins in alleged murder during altercation at party in Magalia

3-5-2008 California:

OROVILLE — Testimony got under way Tuesday in the trial of an Auburn parolee charged with a Magalia murder.
Darrin Lee Pacheco's attorney told the Butte County Superior Court jury the defendant was acting in lawful defense of his brother when Paul Prestridge, 28, was fatally stabbed with a kitchen knife during a physical altercation on Sept. 3, 2006, at a family barbecue at the brother's Crescent Drive Magalia home.

In his opening remarks to the eight-woman, four-man jury, deputy district attorney Kurt Worley acknowledged Prestridge initiated the fight by accusing the brother of befriending a child molester and throwing the first punch that night.

The prosecutor said witnesses will testify the defendant's brother had Prestridge in a headlock on the floor, when the 37-year-old suspect began "flailing his arms" over the combatants after retrieving two kitchen knives.

A woman at the party suffered a cut to a hand taking one of the knives away from him, according to Worley.

The mortally wounded man tried to punch the defendant's brother at least once more before collapsing and dying near the front door from a stab wound to the heart, said the prosecutor.

In asking the jury to acquit Pacheco of murder and assault charges, Chico defense attorney Robert Marshall contended the defendant was legally justified to prevent his brother from suffering death or serious injury.

Marshall said he would prove Prestridge, who had also spent time in prison, had a history of punching people, including a motorist and a fellow employee.
Witnesses will testify that when the name of a man came up from whom they might be able to purchase some marijuana that night, Prestridge claimed he was a "chomo," which is prison parlance for child molester, said Marshall.

When Prestridge questioned how Rick Pacheco could allow his daughter to go over to a child molester's house, and called him a "chomo lover," Marshall told the jury the defendant tried to mollify him by saying "I never saw any paperwork" to that effect.

The defense attorney alleges that when told to leave, Prestridge rushed at the defendant's brother, punching him several times in the face and drawing blood.

He said a reasonable person under that situation would also have believed Pacheco's brother was in "imminent danger of death or serious injury."

Among those present during the start of the fight, was Prestridge's fiancee, Mindy Johnson, who told the jury he had proposed marriage to her earlier that night.

She testified to only seeing her boyfriend slap the defendant's brother once with an open hand, after backing him against a wall.

She said she jumped on Prestridge's back at that point to try to pull him off, but he was able to fling both her and Darrin Pacheco off him.

Under questioning by Marshall, Johnson testified she took her oldest child across the street to her mother's home at that point, because she didn't want the tot to see Prestridge fighting, and also because "he is strong and I knew he could take care of himself."

She was getting ready to return to the party when she heard someone speeding away from the mobile home, the wail of an ambulance and arrived to find her fiancee not breathing on Rick Pacheco's front porch. ..more.. by TERRY VAU DELL-Staff Writer